Jessica Yaniv Simpson’s BC Supreme Court lawsuit against Rebel Media alleging harassment and defamation has been dismissed. Sadly, costs were not granted, but the judgment is a 27-page indictment of JY’s credibility, legal skills, and abuse of the legal system.
To catch you up, Yaniv sued Rebel and Rebel applied for it to be dismissed. This was heard in late May, and the Judge reserved making a judgment until July 12, 2022.
His judgment includes a scathing review of Yaniv’s character and behaviour, describing Yaniv as notorious, highly combative, and a prolific litigant in BC courts and the HRT. The judge specifically references six court cases and Yaniv’s waxing HRT cases, and included citations where the tribunal member had said Yaniv was deceptive, punitive, and racist. It’s also noted that Yaniv’s appeals were lost, and these cases gained widespread attention – including from Rebel.
The Judge then references the infamous Blaire White video, and how it led to criminal charges. The judgment includes details about White’s allegations that JY was engaged in illicit behaviour online with underage girls.
The judgement goes on to question Yaniv’s claim that he had a previously “valued and unblemished reputation in the Province of British Columbia and elsewhere in Canada and throughout the world” and that Rebel vilified him. Rebels defense to these claims was that they were making fair comment, the claims were true, and that it was responsible communication and reporting on the topics of Yaniv preying on vulnerable immigrant women, being deceitful by pretending to be a woman for voyeuristic reasons and pretending to be disabled to use free assisted transit, being a pedophile, and a violent criminal.
The Judge wrote that he was satisfied that members of the public would have a genuine interest in these things, and that if they were true they would affect the welfare of all citizens. He added that Yaniv’s online and public conduct can be fairly described as notorious and controversial.
When measuring if Yaniv’s case had any merit, the Judge ruled out any chance of Yaniv having a case for harassment, since the Rebel reporters were just doing their job, and no such tort exists anyways. However, the Judge agreed that some of Rebels claims in their YouTube series about Yaniv were potentially defamatory if found to be false. The Judge didn’t say if they were true or false – just that they met the bar for being defamatory IF they were false.
Rebel argued that the case should be dismissed because JY had been unable to refute their defenses because the alleged defamatory statements were true and/or fair comment. The Judge agrees that Rebel’s comments were in the public interest, and they could be interpreted as deductions or conclusions drawn from what Rebel had seen about JY.
JY did prepare an affidavit responding to Rebels dismissal application, it didn’t actually say anything about the accuracy of what Rebel had said. In other words, JY didn’t do anything to disprove what Rebel had said, he just thought they were being mean.
Regarding Rebels assertions that JY bullies vulnerable immigrant women, the Judge noted that the factual basis for these claims comes from the HRT waxing decision.
Regarding Rebels assertions that JY is violent, dangerous, and criminal, the factual basis for that claim comes from the Blaire White video and the criminal prosecutions. Yaniv tried to argue he didn’t have a “taser”, but a charged energy weapon, which he suggests is different. The Judge wasn’t having it.
Regarding Rebels assertions that Yaniv feigns disabilities, the factual basis for this is in various videos showing JY engaged in physical activities like running and wielding a cane as a weapon, inconsistent with other appearances showing Yaniv in a scooter.
The Judge did reference Yaniv’s response that they have various debilitating conditions (fibromyalgia, complex regional pain syndrome, chronic fatigue
syndrome, severe bilateral sensoneural hearing loss, central pain sensitivity, sciatica, central sensitization syndrome and many other health ailments), but says Yaniv’s affidavit didn’t say how they require him to use a scooter. Rebel, on the other hand, was able to use medical records (likely sourced from MeowMix’s library) to show that Yaniv had seen a doctor about using a scooter for reasons entirely different than what Yaniv cites in his affidavit (dizzy spells, ataxia, falls)
Yaniv’s burden was to show that Rebel had acted dishonestly, but the best Yaniv could do was suggest that they were acting unreasonably or outrageously. This doesn’t defeat their defense of fair comment.
Yaniv also argued that being labelled a pedophile and “pretending to be a woman” was the most damaging. The Judge was able to cite several sources that support Rebels claims. The Judge didn’t outright call Yaniv a pedo, but he admitted to case law and court history several clauses that reference Yaniv’s pedophilic behaviour, including sexual chat logs with girls 13-16 years old and conversations about naked girls in change rooms. Rebel showed that these screenshots and records exist on several websites and the Blaire White video, and the Judge also referenced Yaniv’s Township of Langley application to organize and host a topless pool party for kids as young as 12 where parents are banned.
Some of the video clips shown by Rebel include Yaniv taking a picture with young girls in the background in the bathroom, and referencing how Yaniv traveled to Toronto to meet a catfish and a young girl at a hospital. Yaniv provided no evidence about these claims at all and no defence. The Judge ruled that they met the bar for fair comment.
With the above evidence submitted, the Judge ruled that Yaniv didn’t meet the required burden to move ahead with a defamation case against Rebel. With this in mind, the Judge ruled the case could be closed, but wanted to add further facts to the judgment anyways.
The last test Yaniv had to meet was to prove he had been harmed by Rebels words. Yaniv argued that Rebel caused “significant emotional distress, anxiety, depression, and suicidal ideation,” and that they have caused “extreme distress” and “multiple suicide attempts.“
The Judge said Yaniv’s claim of having a previously unblemished reputation was a lie, and that Yaniv was already the target of extensive adverse publicity from multiple sources. Rebel was just one of many.
Further, the Judge added (again, he didn’t need to…) that Yaniv had CHOSEN to engage in this public arena and Rebels attacks on JY were often matched by Yaniv’s targeted attacks on Rebel via social media, and that Yaniv often resorts to litigation or threats of litigation to stifle criticism.
Even if Yaniv HAD been harmed, that harm is still weighed against the public interest. The Judge accepts that Rebel had at least some motivation to warn the public about what they believed to be true about Yaniv, even if some find it offensive. The Judge concedes that some of the actions engaged in by Rebel were probably over the line.
With all the above in mind, the Judge granted Rebels application to dismiss and tossed Yaniv’s case. He then moved on to the matter of costs. Rebel wanted full costs granted, alleging it was a SLAPP lawsuit. The hallmarks of a typical SLAPP case involve a weak claim, a history of threats of litigation, and scant evidence, which JY nails across the board. However, another hallmark is that plaintiffs are usually well-funded and use disproportionate resources to bully a weaker defendant. In this case, Rebel is far more well-funded than Yaniv. This imbalance tilted the Judge towards making each party bear their own costs.
In short…there is now BC Supreme Court case law that includes the Blaire White video, accusations of Yaniv being a pedo and the public interest in that, and claims that Yaniv has abused the court system for personal gain. I wonder how JY feels about that, especially since this can now be used as a reference in every future defamation case Yaniv tries to start. #Karma.
Read the full judgment at this link, or download it below.
36 thoughts on “BC Supreme Court Writes Scathing Judgment of Jessica Yaniv Simpson; Dismisses Rebel Lawsuit”
Teeee…..fucking……heee, AWESOME! I plumped up a little reading this!
If I could use the clapping emoji, I would. The very thing Jonboy was trying to avoid happened… I haven’t read it yet, but based on your article, this document is damning to Jon’s future… or lack thereof… because the Judge has pretty much gathered everything… paedophile, racist, litigant scammer, questionable credibility, all round asshole… into one document and cited evidence for it, too and all at a request away for the lawyers of any victim Jon tries to target in the future.
Costs would’ve been the icing on the cake, but you can’t have it all. I was worried when the Judge said they were going to reserve their decision… but as we can see, it was probably because he wanted to do his due diligence and probably check into some of the claims from both sides. Needless to say, he was probably disgusted at the kind of person Jonboy was.
“Charged energy weapon” had me lmfao… Jonboy thinks we’re on Star Trek or something.:D
I love it! I hope that fat disgusting pig reads it over and over, and realizes all the cases he’s about to lose. Bring on Amy Hamm. If Yaniv was smart (he isn’t) he would offer to settle now with her. Amy must be over the moon with this decision
LOL, lard ass had a FB post earlier today celebrating someone else’s win against ICBC. My crystal ball see’s him attempting to milk more out of that minor fender bender.
The fat loser got owned.
With this, there’s no point in Yaniv ever filing a case against anyone ever again. The defense can merely reference this, and whatever case Yaniv thinks it has is sunk. This is gonna affect Yaniv’s employment prospects as well. His dreams of becoming a lawyer will be over once someone explains this to him in detail. Is it too late for SFU to issue a refund? No point in attending tbh
The lawyer ship sailed long ago. The path from of taking one semester at a community college’s legal secretary program to an LLB or a JD would be long and difficult for anyone with a normal brain. Its impossible for a spastic like jon.
As for SFU I doubt he’s handed over a penny yet so nothing to be refunded.
there never was point in attending; if by chance he were pass courses nobody would ever employ him. yaniv has ruined his life beyond repair and is unemployable.
Speaking of his employment prospects reminds me of Jonboy’s interviews with Blaire White and Mark SJW Hughes. I’m pretty sure that when the subject of the wax-my-balls cases came up, Jon said something to the effect of they didn’t have to become aestheticians and they could’ve chosen to be… and he listed a couple of jobs that were stereotypes for immigrants like taxi drivers.
I wonder how he feels about that now that his employment prospects are practically non-existent and that nobody would trust him with a paper route or a mop let alone a taxi or as a techie. Last job he had sounded more like he’d been roped into a pyramid scheme than proper employment.
Well, Jon, you can always dream about the hot, smart, popular, bubbly lawyer who works in a busy law firm, dealing with personal and work drama by day – maybe trading catty words with the other hot lawyer in the office – then going on dates with beautiful lesbians by night and making you colleagues jealous with all the details next day… then you can wake up in your dank, messy, apartment alone and realize that dream is so far out of reach now, you may as well get a hair cut and call yourself Jonathan again.
That will be on record, and since this assessment of Jabba the Yaniv’s frivolous lawsuit-predatory court abuse won’t deter the delusional she/male a true mental health assessment will follow in the near future. A Narcissist who has deep psychosis enjoys making other people miserable and has no empathy or morals. A Psychopath-inward, and a Sociopath, in public. There will be no deterrence, and misuse of all public services, misrepresentations, frauds, and predatory abuse of minors will land Jabba Yaniv in a mental health facility to protect society.
Yaniv just got a big target put on his back.. the pedo hunters that want to hurt him now have verification that he’s a pedo. They are coming for Yaniv and they are going to get him.
You live in fear Yaniv, you brought all this on yourself. You still have Amy Hamm, your going to lose that one too and pay for that one. The RMCP has a similar lawsuit against you, you are going to get fucked with that. Your stunt at you mom’s place is going to take you out.
Jon, you way of living is about to drastically change. Thank you for participating in The game of Life. You lost Jon, you lost. You also still sound like a middle age man.
Anyone believe in the multiverse theory? Can anyone believe that there might be a universe out there where Yaniv has friends? Maybe one where he isn’t a trash human and hated everywhere goes? Perhaps in another universe he’s successful, popular, and attractive? A universe where he isn’t a complete coward, or where he’s actually some of the things claimed on its previous twitter bio. Maybe somewhere out there, in that Multiverse, there’s a version of Yaniv that’s educated and intelligent. Perhaps this person would be a value to society, and not just a burden to everyone around him. If that does exist, what sins did our universe commit to get stuck with this version?
Depends on which multiverse theory you believe in, i mean the DC Multiverse got the Dark Multiverse too.
Maybe it happened in one of those universes? I mean sure all of those universes so far got destroyed rather quickly but it might have been possible there.
To address the theory/fact that the reason Rebel wasn’t awarded costs – “another hallmark [of SLAPP] is that plaintiffs are usually well-funded and use disproportionate resources to bully a weaker defendant. In this case, Rebel is far more well-funded than Yaniv.” I wish the court would’ve used semantics and said something along the lines that “well funded” could have a myriad of interpretations, and that JYS was well funded with time (being chronically unemployed and all), has his mother’s financial backing, and a little education in law so far (using that against fatass would’ve been golden) and awarded Rebel costs. It is at their description after all, correct? I agree with other people who have theorized that the only way to make Yaniv stop the vexatious BS is to slapp him (pun intended) with costs. I can’t wait to see his condo foreclosed on!! Tick tock…
Discretion* not description. 2022 is the year yaniv will officially fall. And hopefully, people will continue to give him various forms of “payback” for as long as he’s been dishing it out to people…soooo 15 more years? That’s a lot of milk forthcoming from this lolcow. Lol. Can’t wait to hear Trevor Dunen gloat gloriously after reading this. Ha!
You gotta love the list about the alleged defamatory statements made by Yaniv under point 35, under which Yaniv lists 35 alleged defamatory statements that Rebell made against him.
Lets take a look at them shall we?
a) Is a “disabillity faker”
I think this is pretty much proven at this point. First you have to drive around in a fatty scooter than you run to hit someone with your cane…
b + c) Is a terrorist / enables or supports terrorists.
Lets take a look at the word terrorist…
Google tells us the following: “The word was originally applied to supporters of the Jacobins in the French Revolution, who advocated repression and violence in pursuit of the principles of democracy and equality.”
Google also tells us the definition: “a person who uses unlawful violence and intimidation, especially against civilians, in the pursuit of political aims.”
To me that sounds pretty much like a spot on description of Yaniv.
d + e) Is not transgender / is not a woman.
At the time those statements were made Yaniv was still a biological untransitioned male. So those statements were 100% true.
Now one could argue that Yaniv is still a biological male, that just got his dick chopped off, but lets not do that its just a 9 inch deep rabbit hole.
f + g) Is a sex offender / enables or supports sex offenders.
Idk about the law, but if you try to “sext” with minors, that makes you at least in my opinion a sex offender at best.
I dont know about the enabeling or support part, or where that comes from, but than again i think you only added that point to blow your list up even more.
h) Is a public menace
Well… Yeah… If people feel the need to put up warning posters about you and your behavior i think you fit right into that category.
i + j) Was in posession of a / supports or enables peole who illegally possess firearms.
I dont know about the owning factor, but Yaniv himself said he can get one whenever he wants when he was threatening his first catsfish.
So again i would say yeah the suport factor is pretty much given here.
k) Was in possession of a Taser
Well you showed it on the stream with Blaire White. It doesnt matter if they are called a conducted energy weapon / device, if you pull one out people will call tham Tasers. Just like most people call building blocks Legos.
i + m) preys upon individuals / supports or enables those who who do so
Lets take a look… Riley, Toni, Sara, Emma, JessR, Katie, Madison, Nicole, Raygen, Ashley, MandaPanda, Amy Hamm, Andrew Barron, Donald Smith, Kari simpson, Gaffka.
You sure you are not Preying on individuals? Because it pretty much looks like it from my point of view.
n) does not shave their genitals.
I wanted to say its too much of a low hanging fruit, but than i remembered that those fruits were already removed and composted.
Seriously who writes that in a court document?
o + p + q) Is a con-man / commits fraud or participated in fraudulent activities / enables or supports those who commit fraud
Aside from your little service Dog , disabillity, and his “i am an influencer send me free sex toys” scams.
If you google the company that made his Tasers (Damsel in Defence) at least on my computer the 7th thing that google spits out is a warning that the company might pull an MLM Pyramidscheme.
So yeah i would say all the boxes come pre ticked already.
r + s) Is a man pretending to be a woman / is a gender bender
First of all, its the same as point d + e.
Second, it wasnt Rebel Media that said that, it was us.
t + u + v + w + aa) Is a Pedophile / Enables or supports Pedophiles / Abuses Children / enables or supports those who abuse Children / Enables or supports child molestation.
Again… If you are trying to “sext” minors, and also if you “flash” your moobs to minors on streams, YES YOU ARE A PEDOPHILE. At least in my Opinion.
But just in case you forgot who i am talking about… Riley 13, JessR 14, Madison 17 (You even tried to get her 9 year old sister into it too), Raygen 16, Ashley 14
So yeah… i would say that your behavior ticks all of those boxes.
x + y) Is involved in an incestual relationship with his mother / enables and support those who are
Again it wasnt Rebel Media who said that it was us and it started as a joke, learn to take jokes. I mean it runs in your family you mother took you too.
z) was sexually molested as a child
First, that wasnt a statement that was a question Rebel Media asked you (Probably in an attempt to get a rise out off you to get some content, not the most elegant tactic but a tactic none the less)
bb) is transgender to look at naked teenagers
Topless swimming pool party, and taking photos in female bathrooms with children in the background. Do i need to say more?
cc+ dd + ee + ff) Goes after immigrant women / enables or supports harassment of immigrants / bullies people / enables or supports bullying
14 wax my balls cases against immigrant women, 77 racist photos at least in meowmix’s photo section, multiple screenshots of you cyberbullying people in the same section should proof the first 3 points.
As for your scams… really you wanna go there? okay.
Your adopt a street scam, your fake service dog scam, the condo fire scam, your car crash scam, your brain tumor scam, your cops 4 cancer scam.
ii) flew to Toronto to meet a minor
Well you flew to toronto to see Sara (your catfish you remember?) and her 2 year old daughter (which doesnt exist) So technically this is correct.
I love how you can just look at all the points Yaniv tried to make out as false and instantly be able to say Nope that happened we got the proof right over there.
Also i spend way too much thought on this but i had 30 minutes to spare, so fuck it.
In the end i can only say Yaniv could have made that list way shorter since 14 points of that list (c, g, j, m, n, q, r, s, u, w, y, aa, dd, and ff) are only there to blow up the list.
Not only did Yaniv actually do everything He tried to state as defamatory on his list, and we do have the proof that he did those things, but Jonathan Jessica Serenity Yaniv Simpson is also a complete and utter moron.
Since Chris asked us once to be a little bit more polite and only write things we would tell the person to his face, i will do exactly that.
I hope Jonathan Jessica Serenity Yaniv Simpsons suicide attempts will one day stop being attempts. The world would be a better place without that massive blob of fat and hate in it.
(And yes i know that makes me a blob of hate too, but i can live with that.)
That court judgement is the best resume and reference list anyone can give JY’s future attempts for gainful employment. Sucks that costs weren’t granted, so I hope Rebel at least appeals costs.
Many of you back at the time were pointing out that Fat-Boy hadn’t thought this one all the way through–i.e. that he was just providing Rebel with the perfect vehicle to introduce all this evidence to show that yes, yes Fat Jon, you ARE in fact a pedo, serial fraudster, etc. This really is a case of “hoist on his own petard.”
Well if Jon has shown us anything, it’s that he’s unable to think more than one move ahead. I think he was just focused on getting all the bad shit about him “OFF THE INNERNET!! NOW! NOW! NOW!” and covering up his sins and hit that reset button. Definitely didn’t expect to cement it all in a court ruling.
He’s stupid, a narcissist, a man child and thinks he’s smarter and better than everyone else… that is a bad combo.
@The Dead Name Game…lol, the A level spin doctors & web sanitizers that are currently cleaning up after Hunter Biden wouldn’t be able to cover jon’s tracks. He is so epically fucked not even going into witness protection would afford him a new life. Even if his slate was somehow wiped clean the problem is jon himself….within no time that dummy would be doing something new that would bring ridicule and scorn.
Being institutionalized might not only be the best for society but for fatso as well.
More like “hoist on his own neovag” – he had the “petard” surgically removed.
@Jim Norton I was just thinking the same when I read the document. It covers events up to about 2020 and Rebel probably stopped reporting on Jonboy on the advice of their lawyer. But Jon has done so much more shit since then. It’s like you said, Jonboy is a fuck-up that just can’t help getting himself into trouble.
@The Dead Name Game, correct that its only (lol, “only”…there’s no shortage of FACTS from this case that will permanently impugn jon’s motivations & behaviors) up to 2020. That’s alright, from there to current can be covered in his impending criminal libel trial. 🙂
He is so completely fucked!
Oh, the wicked TRANSPHOBIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA ! from that judge.
I sincerely wish fuckface would go back on Twitter so we can say all this to it’s face.
And taunt it mercilessly about everything it has ever touched going totally to shit.
And, with multiple criminal convictions and future HUGE judgements against it, life is over…
Girls can dream, can’t they? *bats eyes*
LOLOOOOOL at the 400lb. pedo fraudster incel!!!!
Sue the judge now. Dooooo it.
Also – It’s going to be hilarious if any of Yaniv’s classmates at SFU reference any of this during discussions of modern case law. Yaniv will spaz right the fuck out.
Somebody who has access to the same SFU groups as Yaniv needs to link them to here so they can see how lucky they’ll be to be in class with such an educated scholarly attorney to be. HAHAHAHAHA! Word on facebook is incel boy is already starting to deep dive with SFU groups into his favorite fetish of menstrual products. What an absolute fuckup. Gets called a pedo and pervert by the courts no less and immediately tries to double down on that fact.
Call a realtor, sell your condo, move to a cheap trailer park in Nova Scotia or Saskatchewan. Trade your smart phone for a landline. Take up a new hobby, research dung beetles for all I care. Just know it’s time to withdrawal and stop giving people the daily train wreck you give us. Give your reputation a rest for Pete’s sake. And finally get some psychiatric or professional help. You’re a mess.
Miriam Yaniv – Driving W/O Due Care Charge – Hearing July 21, 2022
Fire Alarm, False Reporting, Assault Charge – FXD – July 25
Defamatory Libel Charge – APW/FAW – July 25
VCHA Lawsuit PreTrial Conference Aug 23
Remember everyone, when sharing warnings about Yaniv, you no longer have to say “Alleged” when you say Yaniv is a pedophile. Because now it’s a matter of public record. He’ll also NEVER be able to file a defamation of character suit because the judge put it on record that Yaniv’s reputation was already a wreck.
I can’t wait until the next court appearances. This losing streak of his is well deserved. Big boy court is destroying him.
Yaniv was never going to be a lawyer, he only went that route because he wanted to put up the front that he’s not a loser with no future and to also score some tuition money. He doesn’t want people to think he’s going nowhere in life, so he creates lies trying to fool people. The thing is nobody is fooled anymore.
Yaniv tries to create a persona he could be proud of but fails at it because he’s low IQ.
Times must be tough, fatso has purchased some pretty shitty facebook followers. All his recent likes are from people who look like they should be running email scams.
Any updates on pedo John or has he gone quiet?
I started making already Jonny boy.
jon, you can run (ok…well, maybe you can’t actually run…its more short bursts of quick waddling) but you can’t hide from your proven predatory behavior. The SFU students & faculty are aware of your history and the threat you present, how about you just stop this charade of attempting to get a degree. We know and more importantly if you’re honest you know you’ll NEVER complete a degree. You’re too stupid, too lazy and candidly with your shitty health I’m not convinced you’ll live long enough, so how about you just save everyone the inevitable grief of you being on campus and just quit now.
Oh, and as an aside I admit to enjoying the daily JY Quote of the Day for the cringe value but today’s had me gagging. “there’s so much cream on my pussy anyone wanna lick it up?”. I’ll be drinking my coffee black from now on.
He hasn’t even attended a class and he is all over social media SFU groups. This is another example of mental illness. The word is out about Jabba Yaniv, stay clear or you will be stalked and likely end up abused in some way. Delusions of Grandeur: I’m thinking of studying Law, no degree yet but will be writing the Bar Exam…..absolute rubbish. Stalking minors online, and now a campus to target? At least the students are adults.
JY delayed his jail sentence by firing his lawyer again.